Two weeks ago I was in confession, admitting sins of jealousy and just generally not being happy with what I have, when the priest spoke up. This particular priest doesn't usually have much to say in the confessional, at least to me, so it intrigued me immediately. He told me I needed to have a spirit of contentment and gave some other good advice that I instantly knew I would forget. And I did. But the phrase "spirit of contentment" hasn't left my mind since.
I have thought about it. Struggled with it. Tossed it around and decided I know I need it, I want it, but I have absolutely no idea how to obtain it.
What I have no trouble with is outlining how I am not content.
Most of my discontent centers around finances, not surprisingly. If only we just had a little more. I wouldn't have to worry about the grocery list, or that dreaded second week of the pay period. Our kids could go to private school. We could have cable t.v. and a van. And maybe a nicely landscaped back yard.
Don't get me started on the house. I spend a lot of time upset at its very small size, our dreary neighborhood and, until last summer, the fact that it had only one bathroom (thanks to my awesome father-in-law, we have now increased our bathroom count by a half!). Our bed is broken and I covet one day owning a dresser and bedside tables that are not hand-me-downs from my childhood.
I could go on and on. Yes, I spend way too much time thinking about what I don't have.
A couple nights ago I was thinking about this and started to wonder if maybe we were considered lower class. At least we must be lower middle.
Oh, how embarrassingly naive I was. Painfully naive.
I couldn't find a consensus about exact income levels and class, but it's safe to say no one would consider us lower or even lower middle. Oh no. By some accounts we would even fall into the upper middle class.
That was the kick-in-the-pants I desperately needed.
More than half of the country makes less than we do. Or, I should say, more than half of the country makes a lot less than we do.
In my little world, everyone has a lot. People own big homes, pretty furniture, shop at Target whenever they want, and their kids are dressed beautifully. The church I attend, the stores I frequent, the museums, the parks - they are all, for the most part, filled with people who have a lot of money. They drive vans, eat out, hire babysitters, and own iPhones and iPads. They aren't filthy rich, but they are living well.
I was starting to think everyone did. But they don't.
Just because I don't know them doesn't mean they don't exist. Just because I don't drive through their neighborhoods or go to their churches doesn't mean they aren't there. Maybe I should start going there more often.
The fact is millions of people have less than I do. Millions of people probably dream about owning our tiny house, or our two cars. They probably long to live in our safe neighborhood where their kids can play in their fenced-in backyard without fear of being shot. They wouldn't mind that the fence isn't a privacy fence, or that it's broken, or that we can't afford to fix up the half of our yard that doesn't have grass.
While I wish we had a little more so I could buy my kids more new clothes, millions of people would be more than happy to get a summer wardrobe at the nice Salvation Army down the street. They'd have a field day in the bags of my clothes that I've sent to the attic because I don't like them much anymore. And they'd surely eat well on the food we can afford, even on a tight budget.
And school? I'm pretty confident they'd be more than thrilled to live in our very sought-after public school district.
It's so easy to focus on what I don't have. It's human nature to want more comfort, to pay too much attention to what those around you are doing, buying, consuming. But it brings me great stress, so why do it? Comparing myself to others doesn't make me happy. It stings.
Having a spirit of contentment, on the other hand, would be so freeing. To truly be happy with what you have or, for that matter, with nothing (because, really, it's about being happy separate from material things, isn't it?), sounds liberating.
It's what we are called to do: Indeed, religion with contentment is a great gain. For we brought nothing into the world, just as we shall not be able to take anything out of it. If we have food and clothing, we shall be content with that. (Timothy 6:6-8)
Our possessions are temporary. It's not why we're here. They don't make us holier or improve our relationships. In fact, you could make a strong argument that they do the exact opposite.
Three years ago, I would have sworn to you that I would know true contentment if I could only have a child. I would have bet my life on it.
And what am I doing now? I am praying and hoping for another. Not a second, but a third.
I highly doubt my priest remembers my confessions, or even knew for sure that it was me two Saturdays ago, but if he did, he could definitely draw the conclusion that I have a serious problem with contenment. Maybe that is why he said what he said - he was tired of hearing the same confession from me, that I always want what others have. Wanting children is noble and good, so perhaps there is more patience there. But now it's getting silly.
My pride is hoping that it was, instead, the Holy Spirit nudging him to offer the contentment advice. I suppose it doesn't matter, though. It's between me and God and He surely knows I need help.
So what am I going to do about it? I'm not sure. I think I need to change my outlook. Try to remember those who have less than I do. Every time I am jealous of a material item someone has that I don't, I will remind myself of the average income in the country and the harsh reality that so many live with so little.
I will try to remember that if I am truly happy, I could live free of things. And, in that spirit, I will try to get rid of things I don't need and stop myself from buying new. See if we can live with less and make it more like a game (it worked with cutting cable!).
I'll also remind myself that my husband works hard for us (two jobs) and provides us with so much. To be anything less than content is a slap-in-the-face to him. And I'll also tell myself that we'd have a lot more money if I worked. I absolutely love being a stay-at-home mom to Clara and Luke and I'd have it no other way. So if I put it in that perspective, I am content with what we have (or don't have).
I remember years ago, when we lived in a bigger home, visiting a friend whose house was much smaller than ours. I thought it would be so nice to live more modestly, have less to clean and less clutter. Less to worry about, I thought. That just goes to show that my problem with discontent may have less to do with wanting more, and more to do with wanting something different than I have.
I can only hope that I can begin to look at my surroundings with rose-colored glasses. That I can see and appreciate all that I have, apart from the material, and that I can truly have a spirit of contentment. Because, honestly, with my loving husband and two beautiful kids, our families and friends, and my faith, I have more than I could have ever dreamed.
I love your honesty. Great post.
ReplyDeleteI used to confess jealousy all the time too...but now with God's grace, I'm ok with it,(I think) I always think of these priest's words of advice for me....
I remember one priest always telling me, that we were rich in virtue and that was much more important. He's right. (about it being more important)
Another priest told me to go back and sit in the pew and to take a few minutes, several minutes to start at the beginning of me, and thank God for everything in my life. Everything. You know, not one thing was material? Nothing.
There will always be people much poorer than us. Always someone suffering more.
Another priest told me that if allowed, we could not even walk one day in another's shoes. Their lives might look much better than ours, but we couldn't carry what they carry. And they couldn't carry what we do. Our lives are all unique and Masterly woven just for us.
I can completely relate to a lot of what you said in this post. The spirit of contentment is a hard thing to achieve when we are constantly comparing ourselves to others. But I have found a lot of young moms are right where I am financially and the people I am envious of are not surprisingly older and more established than my little family just starting out. Maybe one day we will get to where they are but even if I don't, I will have to work to be happy with where I am and what I have.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your honesty Karey!
Hear you. I am so glad you are able to look at your feelings so honestly.
ReplyDeletePraying for you on your journey.
K,
ReplyDeleteYou do such a great job putting your feelings and observations down to where we can really relate to them! I have also been nursing a spirit of discontment lately and there are times when I get that clarity of "How in the world could I possibly want MORE?".
We are struggling with our very tiny home (1140 sq ft for 5 people) and at the end of the day I thank God for the wonderful roof over our head and that we had the room to open up our home to my two teenage cousins! God does provide enough, I just have to remind myself of that very often - especially on the rainy days when the house seems even more crowded :)
On another note, I just love your family and I ams so glad that you are finding peace! Your peace will flow to your children in ways that will last a lifetime!
Oh, K! what a beautiful post. No doubt the Lord is working in your heart this Lent. What a gift!!
ReplyDeleteI struggle with discontentment at times, too. But one thing I have learned is to thank God for every single thing that happens in my life. Even the sorrows. So, thank Him for feeling discontented, thank Him for all your worries, and He will transform your heart and give you more peace.
One thing that someone told me when I get to having those kind of feelings of wanting a bigger house, etc is that the ppl you see that do have the big cars, expensive wardrobes, etc also have TONS of debt! Nowadays you can get just about anything with credit and who knows how much debt they are in.
ReplyDeleteRight now I am obsessed with my body image and knowing that if I don't lose wt soon we probably won't have great chances of having another baby. I was the same when wanting to have just ONE child and now I feel bad for wanting another! I guess the real answer is that nothing and no one can fill us like God!! I know it is easier said than done, but I have been trying to focus more on being thankful that I have a healthy body (compared to some). It takes practice to change my way of thinking, but I am working on it!
I am gonna send up some prayers for you and pray that you can find peace sweet girl!!
Love you!
" some other good advice that I instantly knew I would forget" Yes! I'm not the only one.
ReplyDeleteThis is really beautiful. Every time I feel like we are so, so poor I look up the national poverty income levels. We are not poor-we'd have to have several more kids to be "poor". But how new furniture and a bigger grocery budget taunt us...
This is so honest and beautiful. Thank you for sharing. Our family lives in the "donut hole" we are a great neighborhood surrounded on all sides by a very low-income, violent, unsteady area with many vacant homes and horrible public schools. In fact, our home is in the horrible public school district (when we bought our house I thought I'd never get pregnant and it wouldn't matter...oops!). So even though we are def. middle class, we have a lot more than most of the people who live near us, so it's not so easy to forget. BUT, I still struggle with contentment because of what friends and other family have which we don't.
ReplyDeleteHave you ever read the book One Thousand Gifts by Ann Voskamp? It has changed my life in regards to gratitude and contentment. She's amazing.
Thank you for a great reflection.
This is a great post.
ReplyDeleteOne more thing...regarding the folks you see out and about...eating out...shopping...being upper middle class in the way you are seeing.
ReplyDelete3 words: credit card debt.
When you get to know more about the real financial picture of most families it is a financed pay later life style that one is seeing.
You've written a beautiful post here. I don't struggle so much with this because most of my friends are in the same boat I am so I do not have much to compare myself to. But every so often, I do find myself wishing I could afford a Sephora lipstick, a Shabby Apple dress, or even just to not have to second-guess whether I really need everything I put into my grocery cart. We live on one income, in an old neighborhood that is just okay, drive old cars, can't afford Catholic school, and wear clothes from the Goodwill down the street. But we're *happy* this way, really . We have everything we need. We just don't have everything we want, and that's okay. It's good for us.
ReplyDeleteI hope you hold on to your desire to find contentment, and that you do find it in the life you have now.
I think we all deal with something.
ReplyDeleteI covet people who don't have to deal with hormone issues. I literally study them as if they are from another planet because I can just tell by looking at some people they are "healthy".....Then my mind starts going....She has it so easy, she has no idea what its like to wake up and know if she can go or be knocked down. How does she stay so thin being pregnant, does she have any idea how lucky she is? She can go after 4 kids like it's not big deal.....You mean you really wake up ready to go? I ask questions to try and understand what it must be like.....Then I sit and covet....LOL
I have to calm myself down. :) I have access to great health care in my situation and I'm so thankful for that opportunity that I have to just accept it. I think it's getting easier because I'm learning to let go because I don't have the energy for this stuff anymore...But I totally get you!
I covet energy, but then I realize just how damn lucky I am in my marriage and with my kids that I shouldn't want or need for anything else ever....And I do...Because I want all the time.......
Sometimes my daughter gives me a very good example at how I must back God up in a corner demanding things.....Obviously, he can not be backed in a corner. She acts her age screaming when all her needs are met for more, more, more, more.....I see clearly that she is well taken care of and loved, what could she possibly need. But she is sometimes just never content. (I could be reading her wrong but you get my drift) She has no idea how good she has it and then I get a nice big slap in the face as to how I act and what it looks like....Not pretty!
I know that even though my hellmones rule my life, I'm not sure I could handle anyone else's cross. Actually, I know I couldn't. I have friends who have more, bigger and better but I would take my hellmones any day over the hell they live.
And I really do not see what you are talking about with your kids clothes....I think your kids look darling in every single picture I see!!
Are we twins? You and I have so many of the same thoughts and feelings and both have 2 kids very close in age. My biggest struggle is wanting more money too, so life would be easier. Thanks for helping me refocus on what I do have!!
ReplyDeleteThis is a beautiful post, thank you. I'm sitting on reflecting on how I could be more content now. I don't have the same problem-we make good money, but I (the mother) am the breadwinner and work full time, and my husband gets to have all the time he wants with the kids, as well as a full time nanny (he does hourly free lance work and make his own schedule). I always struggle with wanting more traditional roles for us-this arrangement surprised us both (we moved to our current city for my job) and I envy his lifestyle. But we couldn't survive on his income alone and I don't have an option for working part time right now. When I express my frustration to my husband, he reminds me that he could work more to build up his own business, but then we'd have to go through a period where neither of us was focused on our kids, and we don't need the money. This is true and our arrangement is what is best both now and long term for our family but I struggle with wanting to be the one home and managing the kids, the house and home details, and not just the breadwinner. I often think about female nature and where those feminists went wrong in trying to be more like men as opposed to embracing their natures as a starting point for change!
ReplyDeleteAlso, I read an intersting post at conversiondiary.com about goal setting and contentment. She reflects on wanting a bigger house and how before they set goals as a family she would have let her discontenment spill into finding ways to make that happen and therefore continue to feed the discontentment. But once they set some long term financial goals it was easier to accept the house they had beause it fit into the bigger picture of what they were trying to achieve. This helped me think less of the day to day and focus on my goal of being able to work part time in about 5 years. Working full time now and living below our means is a way to continually feel like I'm working toward a bigger goal and comforts me on days I get home late or on Mondays when i'm having baby-withdrawl.
I often read your posts and envy the life you have home with your kids and, BTW, I always think they are dressed adorably, you always look cute and stylish, and your house looks precious. So I really appreciate your honest post and the chane for reflection. It's a great Lenten lesson.
Lastly, I always attribute my constant dissatisfaction with whatever I have to my Irish nature. It's just some place to put the blame! Thank you again for your post.
I think everyone does that to some degree. I love this post! This was a great dose of perspective that I needed. And, I think Little JoAnn is right, many people live beyond their means. I always tell DH, "We're rich where it counts!" :)
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post. It is always good and so very necessary to be reminded of this. There are moments when I struggle with contentment in my work and then I'll see the struggles of others (especially as I review job applications in my HR position) and realize all over again how much I need to be thankful for all that God has blessed me with in this life.
ReplyDeleteI personally think we all struggle with this to some degree. I have to admit that I struggle with it a lot.
ReplyDeleteYou know what? I bet most of those people who wear nice clothes and eat out all the time do not stay at home with their babies. If they do, they only have one or two babies and not any more. Then they go back to work to maintain their expensive lifestyles. (these same people shop at Pottery Barn and buy both kids all brand new stylish clothes).
In the end, money doesn't matter. Houses don't matter or how big they are. Its how well we love one another. (including God, by having a spirit of gratitude). THANK YOU for this awesome post, I needed to read it so badly. One of your best yet.
I just had to comment too on how awesome this post was! I needed to hear it as well. Thank you for your honesty and sharing this with us!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for sharing this! I struggle so much with jealousy too. I remember asking my priest about it in confession once, because I hate it and I know it is just eating away at me. He gave me some very good advice, most of which I've forgotten (but I'll get to confess it again and get more advice!). But one of the things he said is to just focus on the blessings I do have, to try not to think about what others have at all -- what they have does not affect me, so to tell myself that whenever my mind starts to go down that path ... an interesting exercise. Let us know what else works for you. We all struggle with this!
ReplyDeleteThe contentment hits the nail on the head for me too. I often confess that I'm jealous of what others have in just about every confession.
ReplyDeleteYou are not alone! Thanks for posting this. You give such great advice and the other ladies have as well.